We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
In recent years, more and more position players have taken the mound in Major League Baseball. It looked funny the first few times. It later became a trend. Games turned into soft toss sessions in the late innings. Fans saw 50 mph pitches and lopsided scores drift even further. Managers used it to save their bullpens. MLB stepped in. New rules now limit when a position player can pitch. This guide explains what changed, why it changed, and what it means for the sport.
Introduction
Position player pitching is not new. It has existed for decades as an emergency tool. What did change is how often teams used it. As bullpen workloads rose, managers called on non-pitchers more than ever. The league saw the product on the field slide in quality during blowouts. It also saw new risks. To address all of this, MLB set clear limits starting in 2023. Understanding those limits helps you read late-game strategy and see how the league tries to balance fun, fairness, and safety.
What Position Player Pitching Means
A position player is anyone on the roster who is not a regular pitcher. That means infielders, outfielders, and catchers. When one of them takes the mound, it is usually late in a blowout. The goal is simple. Finish the game without using another real pitcher.
Why Teams Used It So Often
There are strong reasons a manager would do this.
First, bullpen management. Teams carry a set number of pitchers. Using one fewer arm in a lost cause makes sense when tomorrow’s game matters more.
Second, roster limits. MLB caps the number of pitchers active at a time. With a fixed number of bullpen arms, managers get creative when the score gets out of hand.
Third, schedule density. Travel, back-to-backs, and extra-inning games add stress. Burning fewer pitchers in a blowout protects against a tired bullpen the next day.
How It Became a Problem
One or two odd outings per season was fine. A steady stream was not. The late 2010s and early 2020s saw a sharp rise. You likely remember viral clips of fielders lobbing slow pitches and hitters grinning through easy swings. What seemed like a funny moment turned into a routine segment. The league saw issues pile up.
The Problems MLB Had to Solve
Game Quality and Fan Experience
Fans pay to watch competition between the best pitchers and hitters. When a shortstop throws mid-50s fastballs, hitters pad stats, pitchers rest, and the competition level drops. The final innings drag with less intensity. For national broadcasts and ballpark crowds, the product feels weaker.
Competitive Integrity
The league must set bounds that keep the game fair. If teams use position players too early, the result can swing further and make stat lines misleading. Allowing a second baseman to pitch with a moderate deficit in the seventh inning, for example, can feel like giving up. It also changes how opponents approach at bats, which muddles competition.
Player Safety
Throwing a baseball off a mound at game speed is a skill. Position players do not train for it the way pitchers do. The risk of arm strain or awkward fielding moments is real. On the other side, hitters face slower and more erratic pitches. Awkward swings, timing disruption, and weird contact can also create risk.
Roster Strategy Distortion
When managers know they can always punt an inning with a position player, it changes how they deploy relievers in earlier innings. That ripple affects competitive balance across a series. The league wants strategy, but within rules that keep teams engaged through nine innings.
The Timeline of Rule Changes
Before Restrictions
For much of MLB history, there was no hard line stopping a position player from pitching. It was rare and reserved for emergencies. As bullpen usage patterns evolved, it became a tool for workload management. Appearances spiked in the late 2010s.
The First Attempt to Rein It In
MLB signaled intent to limit position player pitching as part of broader roster and pace adjustments. Plans were floated to tie usage to extra innings or large scoring margins. Pandemic disruptions delayed a firm rollout. Teams continued to use position players often in 2020 and 2021.
The 2023 Rule That Now Governs the Sport
MLB put clear limits in place starting in 2023. The rule is straightforward and easy to apply.
A position player may pitch only in these cases.
Extra innings at any time in the game once it goes past nine. A trailing team by 8 or more runs at any point. A leading team by 10 or more runs in the ninth inning.
There is one major exception. A player who qualifies as a two way player is not restricted by these limits.
What the Two Way Player Exception Does
Why MLB Created It
Baseball has seen a return of true two way stars who both hit and pitch at a high level. The sport wants to celebrate and support that skill set. It makes no sense to bar a legitimate two way player from pitching simply because he also plays the field or hits as a regular.
How It Works in Practice
Teams can designate a player as a two way player if he meets defined usage benchmarks. Once designated, he can pitch in any situation without the position player restrictions. This keeps the rule focused on its real target. It curbs casual, late inning mop up pitching by non pitchers. It does not block true dual role players from doing their jobs.
Why the New Rule Uses 8 and 10 Runs
Trailing by 8 or More Runs
If you are down by 8 runs, the game is almost out of reach. The league chose a margin where a comeback is unlikely but not impossible. At this point, preserving your bullpen has real value. Allowing a position player protects pitching depth without giving away a still realistic game too early.
Leading by 10 or More Runs in the Ninth
Being up by 10 in the final frame makes a collapse extremely rare. Limiting this to the ninth prevents early surrender by the leading side. This balances respect for the opponent and the fans with a practical path to finish the game safely and efficiently.
Extra Innings Provision
Extra innings are unique. A single game can run deep and burn a bullpen fast. Allowing position players in extras is a simple safety valve. It also pairs with the runner on second rule to push games toward a result while protecting rosters.
How the Rule Changes the Game You Watch
Fewer Novelty Pitches
You will see fewer slow lobs in the seventh or eighth. Most late innings now feature real pitchers unless the game meets the exact rule conditions. The sport looks more like itself late in games, with more standard pitcher hitter battles.
Managers Adjust Their Bullpen Plans
Skippers can no longer reach for a position player in a six run blowout in the eighth. They must map out innings for long relievers or lower leverage arms. Expect more defined roles for the last man in the bullpen. Expect cleaner sequencing with upcoming series in mind.
Better Flow for Broadcasts and Fans
Ending a blowout still goes fast, but with sharper play. The pace feels steadier. The final outs reflect more typical baseball. This improves the experience in the park and on TV.
What Managers Consider Now
Reading the Score and the Inning
Down by 7 runs in the eighth is no longer grounds for a position player. Down by 8 is. Up by 9 in the ninth is not. Up by 10 is. These lines matter. Managers track the margin and immediately reassess after each scoring play.
Protecting Tomorrow
The reason to use a position player has always been to save arms. That logic still applies, only later and in more extreme spots. A manager might hold a long reliever for the next day if the deficit moves from 7 to 8 runs, then hand the ball to a position player to close the night under the rule.
Avoiding Rule Violations
Teams plan ahead to stay within the limits. Staff members track the score margin, inning, and eligibility in real time. Umpires and the league enforce the boundaries. There is no gain in cutting it close and making a mistake that forces a change on the fly.
Impact on Players
Position Players
Fewer will pitch, and those who do will do it under clearer guidelines. Teams may pre identify who can handle the role. Catchers and taller infielders often get the call since they throw often or have a simple delivery that holds up in a low stress inning.
Pitchers
Pitchers still carry the bulk of late innings, even in blowouts. But the rule saves them from needless work in extra innings or when a game passes the defined margins. This can reduce fatigue spikes and keep arms fresher across the season.
Two Way Players
True two way players keep their freedom to pitch whenever needed. The rule recognizes their unique role and prevents accidental penalties when a team wants to deploy them flexibly.
Stats and Records
Cleaner Stat Lines
Fewer position player innings mean fewer outlier at bats for hitters and fewer stat distortions late in games. Pitching stats stay more reflective of pitcher on pitcher competition. Hitting stats have fewer charity swings off 50 mph tosses.
Scoring Consistency
The official scorer still records every play the same way. The difference is that fewer plays will come in skewed contexts. This helps historical comparisons and season long analyses stay grounded in typical game environments.
How We Got to the Breaking Point
Bullpen Trends
Modern pitching strategy leans on relievers who throw hard in short bursts. Starters often go fewer innings than in past eras. This loads pressure on bullpens. When a game turns lopsided, the cost of using yet another reliever can be high. Position player pitching was the release valve, and it got used often.
Roster Limits and the Three Batter Minimum
MLB capped the number of pitchers on the roster and added a three batter minimum for pitchers. These changes improved pace and reduced constant matchups. They also forced managers to think more long term about bullpen use. Position players became a popular choice to bridge junk innings. The new position player limits restore balance to that choice.
Early Results Since the Rule Change
Fewer Appearances by Position Players
The number of such outings has dropped. Games still end, bullpens still survive, but fans see fewer novelty innings in the middle of games. When it happens now, it fits one of three clear conditions.
More Long Relief
Clubs again rely on long relievers and swingmen to cover low leverage frames. These pitchers absorb innings that used to go to position players. This supports competitive play and gives teams a better read on fringe roster pitchers.
Less Confusion About Intent
The lines are clear. If you see a third baseman on the mound in the ninth with a 10 run lead, you know why. If a team down by 6 in the eighth trots out a reliever, that is because the rule says it must. The policy makes motives easier to read.
Edge Cases and Misconceptions
Can a Team Game the Rule With Quick Position Switches
No. A player on defense is either a pitcher or a position player. Once a club decides to use a position player as the pitcher, the innings still must meet the rule. Quick swaps or shell games do not bypass the margin and inning limits.
Does the Rule Kill Fun Moments
No. Fans still see the occasional quirky inning. They also see it at times when the game is clearly decided or in extra innings when rosters need relief. The rule cuts down on routine novelty and keeps big league standards intact.
Does It Hurt Strategy
It narrows one option in medium blowouts, but it opens cleaner planning for everything else. Managers still manage leverage, rest, and matchups. They just do it with guardrails that protect the product.
Team Building After the Rule
More Value in Multi Inning Arms
Clubs now prize reliable multi inning relievers who can cover the sixth through ninth in a lost game. These pitchers reduce the need for a position player and keep games within a professional standard.
Cautious Two Way Experiments
Teams are interested in two way players but must meet the league’s benchmarks to unlock the designation. This keeps the exception narrow and meaningful. It rewards real skill rather than occasional novelty.
Minor League Shuttles
Expect continued use of options to rotate fresh arms from Triple A. When position player innings are off the table in many spots, teams call up rested relievers to survive busy stretches.
What This Means for New Fans
Clearer Rules, Clearer Viewing
As a new fan, you no longer have to wonder why a shortstop is pitching in the seventh with a five run gap. The rule makes late game decisions more predictable. If a position player appears, the game is either deep into extras, a massive deficit for the trailing team, or a massive lead in the ninth for the leading team.
Better Sense of Real Matchups
Most innings you watch will show pitcher against hitter as intended. This helps you learn pitching roles, bullpen pecking orders, and how managers protect arms while still competing.
Looking Ahead
Will MLB Tighten the Rule Further
The league will monitor usage. If position player pitching creeps back in ways that hurt the product, more tuning is possible. On the other hand, if the rule holds usage to rare and reasonable spots, it will likely stay as is.
The Balance MLB Seeks
Baseball must balance player health, strategy, and fan value. The position player rule is a small but visible part of that effort. It promotes competitive innings, honors true two way talents, and preserves bullpens when games are out of reach.
Conclusion
Position player pitching surged because it was a cheap way to save bullpens. It also made too many innings feel unserious. MLB responded with simple limits. Extra innings are fair game. A trailing team by 8 can do it. A leading team by 10 can do it in the ninth. Everyone else must use real pitchers, unless a player is a true two way talent. The result is a cleaner product, better late game strategy, and a safer path through long seasons. The rule does not erase fun. It restores balance. It tells teams and fans what to expect, and it keeps big league baseball looking like big league baseball.
FAQ
Q: When can a position player pitch under the current MLB rules
A: Only in extra innings, when a team is trailing by 8 or more runs at any point, or when a team is leading by 10 or more runs in the ninth inning.
Q: Why did MLB restrict position player pitching
A: To protect game quality, competitive integrity, and player safety, and to prevent routine late inning novelty that distorted strategy and stats.
Q: What is a two way player and how does the exception work
A: A two way player is a legitimate hitter and pitcher who meets league benchmarks. Once designated, he can pitch in any situation without the position player restrictions.
Q: How did the new rule change bullpen management
A: Managers now rely more on long relievers for low leverage innings and use position players only in the defined extreme cases, which keeps late innings more competitive.
Q: Does the rule remove fun moments from the game
A: No. It reduces routine novelty but still allows occasional position player pitching in extras or in clear blowouts, while keeping most innings at a higher competitive standard.