Best Pens for Baseball Autographs

7 Best Pens for Baseball Autographs for 2024

We are reader supported. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Also, as an Amazon affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases.

Getting an autograph from your favorite baseball player may mean a lot to the ardent fan in you. However, a mark from an ordinary pen may turn out to have a short lifespan. To immortalize that signature on a baseball or even a baseball bat, you need to use specialized autograph pens.

These pens’ ink has the special ability to stick on the surface for a long time and give you a lifetime of treasured memorabilia to help you remember and cherish meeting your favorite player. If you are in the market for that special marker or pen to make the memories last, you have come to the right place.

With so many products out there, narrowing down the best choice may become a bit overwhelming, so we have done the homework for you. Read on to find the complete list of reviews of the best pens for baseball autographs carefully handpicked by us.

If you are in a hurry, we simply suggest that you go with our editor’s pick: the Amazon Basics fine-point tip permanent markers (shop now) that are waterproof, durable, fine-point, quick-drying, smear-proof, fade-resistant, clearly visible, and almost everything you could possibly ask for in a pen.

#1. Permanent Markers, Shuttle Art 30 Pack Black Permanent Marker set

The first product on our list is this Shuttle Art black permanent marker set that includes 30 markers, all with black ink. These pens are perfect for detailed markings and signatures on baseballs, and they also work great for other uses, such as writing, drawing, scrapbooking, doodling, and coloring on almost all types of surfaces to show your creative side.

Each marker pen features a durable and versatile fine point that helps in delivering bold and legible marks. These permanent markers come with long-lasting, vivid, quick-drying ink, which is smear-proof, waterproof, and fade-resistant, too.

These markers are also non-toxic and acid-free, and they conform to the industry standards ensuring their safety and lack of toxicity. Children above the age of three years can use these safely without the worry of fumes or toxic chemicals. We were pleased to find that the manufacturer stands behind their product and offers a solid service guarantee as well.

Product features and specifications

  • Weight: 10.8 oz.
  • ‎Fine point
  • 30 markers with black ink
  • Smear-proof and fade-resistant
  • Non-toxic and acid-free
  • Suitable for children above the age of three years

User/Customer Reviews

Many people have said that these markers are much better than rival products, as the points hold up much longer and work better than those of competitors. People have used these markers for various purposes, including things such as drawing on Halloween pumpkins as well as getting baseball autographs, with good results every time. A few customers have warned that these pens do not last too long, though.


The Shuttle Art permanent markers (shop now) are great value pens that come with durable and good quality ink that stays on the applied surfaces for a long time. These work as expected and turn out to be much better than other comparable products in the market. Overall, this product is very affordable and well worth the money.

Check Price Now

#2. Amazon Basics Fine Point Tip Permanent Markers

Next on our list are the Amazon Basics fine point tip markers that feature rich pigment, plus a firm and fine-point tip that gives you sharp, legible, and precise lines. This set includes 24 pieces of non-toxic black permanent markers that are best suited for office or home uses.

These marker pens come with a durable fine point that creates clean lines and bold marks that are perfect for drawing, doodling, and writing. The ink is quick drying as well, so there is no fear of smudging. Additionally, the ink in these pens is also waterproof, smear-proof, and fade-resistant, making them perfect for making a signature last.

These permanent markers write on almost all surfaces, including paper, tape, plastic, stone, metal, wood, glass, and more. They conform to the industry standards regarding toxicity, so you know you’ll be getting a safe product to use. The solid black ink promotes more visibility, especially on light-colored surfaces like autograph papers and standard baseballs.

Product features and specifications

  • Package Measurements: 5.47 in. x 0.67 in. x 0.51 in.
  • Weight: ‎1.6 oz.
  • ‎Fine-point tip
  • Quick-drying and waterproof ink
  • Smear-proof and fade-resistant
  • Solid black ink
  • Works on any surface

User/Customer Reviews

Those who have used these marker pens have said that these last longer than the standard ones and are more affordable, too. People have also said that the color pigment seems to be opaque and bright, and the ink works well on all types of surfaces. A few customers have warned that the marker pen’s ink smells quite strongly, so some people may not like using them if they’re sensitive to strong smells.


The Amazon Basics fine-point permanent markers are solid and long-lasting marker pens that do not cost too much but still work really well. These are some of the most reasonably priced markers you can get and perfectly fit the needs of those looking for the best pen for baseball autographs. Overall, we feel that this product is a good value for your money.

Check Price Now

#3. Sharpie 1735790 Retractable Permanent Markers

Many users have said that these Sharpie retractable markers help you create permanent and brilliant art on almost any type of surface. One of their unique and most beneficial features is that they have a convenient design that allows one-handed operation with no need to put on or remove a cap.

The intense colors are useful in creating eye-popping and vibrant impressions on diverse surfaces like paper, metal, plastic, and many more. Whether you want a baseball, a card, or even a sports cap signed, these are a fantastic choice for making that signature last. The AP-certified and remarkably resilient ink dries up pretty quickly and resists both water and fading.

These marker pens come with a conveniently retractable and precise ultra-fine point which features a precise and narrow tip, too. The product includes 12 black Sharpie permanent markers in the set to last you a long time.

Product features and specifications

  • Weight: ‎4.8 oz.
  • Intensely brilliant colors
  • Ultra-fine point
  • Set contains 12 black Sharpie permanent markers
  • Retractable and precise ultra-fine point

User/Customer Reviews

Many users have said that these permanent marker pens are perfect for writing on baseballs as well any glossy surfaces, such as on photographs. People love the fact that the ink does not smear at all and writes beautifully. Customers also love the retractable feature and the ultra-fine point, which makes it easier to write small. However, a few individuals have warned that the markers did not last as long as expected.


These Sharpie retractable permanent markers are clickable, retractable markers that function almost just like standard pens and work great. The ink is fade-resistant, smear-proof, and stays on almost any type of surface incredibly well. Overall, we feel that these are one of the best pens for baseball autographs that money can buy.

Check Price Now

#4. Sharpie 39108PP Metallic Permanent Markers

Next, we have the Sharpie metallic permanent markers that feature a stunning sheen that stands out on both light and dark surfaces. These pens’ ink has an authentic metallic finish that’s brightly opaque and hard to miss. We love that these pens require no shaking like other products, and you can still have a bright design or signature after using them with more ease than a paint pen.

Besides enjoying the stunning marks without any need for shaking, you can also forget the fear of fading thanks to the quick-drying, fade-resistant, and water-resistant functionality of these metallic pens. The two silver Sharpie markers in each pack come beautifully packaged and ready for use.

This is indeed the gold standard of permanent markers thanks to its outstanding features. These pens are sure to stand out and add more weight to any written message a fan may be receiving from their favorite player.

Product features and specifications

  • Package Measurements: 1.4 in. x 0.9 in. x 9 in.
  • Weight: 0.3 oz.
  • Fade-resistant and water-resistant ink
  • No shaking required
  • Made of plastic material
  • Stunning sheen
  • Durable fine tip for bold marks

User/Customer Reviews

Those who have used these markers have been impressed with the insanely bright coloration as well as the pens’ longevity. People who are into sports love carrying these markers as they come in handy to label their belongings and also have them to use as autograph pens on baseballs, footballs, cricket bats, and plenty more. Customers have praised how great the ink is great for its high visibility.


These silver Sharpie metallic permanent markers are well-designed, long-lasting, and smear-resistant pens that deliver a brilliant mark on any surface. Whether you use them for baseball autographs or any other purposes, you are sure to love these unique and effective permanent marker pens. Overall, we feel that they are absolutely worth the money you pay for them!

Check Price Now

#5. ZEYAR Twin Tip Permanent Markers

As the fifth option, we have the ZEYAR twin tip permanent markers, a set of multi-usage pens that work flawlessly on all types of surfaces. You can use these to write on paper, plastic, glass, metal, wood, rock, and most other surfaces to display your creative side as well as acquire signatures on a wide variety of different items.

Besides getting baseball autographs, these pens can also be used for various other activities such as coloring, painting, drawing, card making, sketching, writing, and drawing, too. The permanent alcohol-based ink quickly dries up in most conditions, but the bold color lasts much longer.

These pens have dual tips that enable you to write in both thin and thick ink for a variety of purposes. The ink is not only richly pigmented but also smear-proof, water-resistant, and fade-resistant. The main set of these pens is available in black, but there are also red, green, and blue options if you’re looking to acquire something a bit different.

Product features and specifications

  • Package Measurements: ‎5.6 in. x 2.8 in. x 0.6 in.
  • Weight: ‎2.39 oz.
  • Dual tips
  • Comfortable to hold
  • 6 pens per pack
  • Water-resistant and smear-proof
  • ‎Ultra-fine and fine-point tips

User/Customer Reviews

People have been impressed with the quality of ink, comfortable grip, and price range of these markers, which makes them a more affordable alternative to Sharpie pens. Users have also said that these markers actually stick to the surfaces on which they’re used and stay on for a long time. Additionally, customers love the thin and thick dual tips of these pens, too.


The ZEYAR twin tip permanent markers are perfect for kids as well as professionals, as they write beautifully on nearly all surfaces. Whether you want to use them for your arts and craft project or as a baseball autograph pen, these pens are a great choice. Overall, we feel that this product is absolutely worth the money.

Check Price Now

#6. Sakura 44181 Identi-Pen Blister Card Permanent Marker

The Sakura Identi-Pen marker is hands down one of the best pens for baseball autographs in the market. If you have a favorite musician, athlete, or movie star, make sure you have one of these markers handy to give them to sign autographs for you. This dual-point multipurpose pen leaves a permanent mark on any nonporous surface.

While one side is a thicker tip for broader lines, the other side has an extra fine plastic point that will not break down under pressure. The ink is resistant to water and writes beautifully on all surfaces such as leather, metal, CDs, plastic, wood, glass, and photographs.

This marker pen has a low odor and meets non-toxicity requirements, so anyone can use them safely for a variety of purposes. However, please bear in mind that they are not recommended for use on fabrics that will be washed, ceramics, or on any surfaces used for food-related purposes.

Product features and specifications

  • Weight: 0.48 oz.
  • Dual points
  • Low odor and non-toxic
  • Available in black color

User/Customer Reviews

Those who have used these pens have said that the ink is just perfect without being too inky or too dry. As a result, these work wonderfully on almost all types of surfaces. People have also mentioned that the size of the pens is good and gives you a comfortable grip, too. Some customers have gone as far as calling it the best pen for writing on plastic, rubber, glass, or any other surface.


The Sakura Identi-Pen permanent marker is the perfect go-to marker for all of your various needs: labeling, drawing, acquiring autographs, and much more. It writes well on all surfaces and looks brilliant, too. Overall, we feel this product has all the features required to be one of the best markers for baseball autographs.

Check Price Now

#7. Dyvicl Premium Metallic Markers Pens

If you like a bit of shimmer and shine, why exclude the autographs you collect? These Dyvicl premium metallic marker pens bring that beautiful sheen to all of your autographed memorabilia, craft projects, and so much more. The marks formed with these pens stand out against both dark and light backgrounds to give an amazing effect.

The Dyvicl package of metallic pens includes two gold and silver pens, each with tips of approximately 1.5 mm as the line width to help you make very clean lines. These pens are the perfect tools you need for drawing, writing, coloring, and more thanks to their ultra-smooth application.

These pens are so lightweight and ergonomic that you can carry them with you anywhere you go, too. Plus, they also have water-based, non-toxic, odorless, and environmentally friendly ink. These versatile markers with strong coverage and brilliant colors that pop can be used to write on mugs, paper, rocks, plastic, and more.

Product features and specifications

  • Package Measurements: ‎5.6 in. x 2.5 in. x 0.5 in.
  • Metallic silver and gold pens
  • Bullet-tip metallic markers
  • Water-based ink
  • Non-toxic and odorless
  • Lightweight and ergonomic

User/Customer Reviews

Most customers have said that these pens have clear marks. However, the tips are supposedly a bit thin but the markings can be thicker with a little more pressure applied. Users have been impressed with the results, which look great on gifts and add value to any surface on which they are used. A few customers have mentioned that while they are smooth and easy to write with, they rub off of slick surfaces quickly.


Whether you want to adorn a Christmas gift or a Halloween card or use one as a pen for your sports memorabilia, these Dyvicl premium metallic marker pens are hands down one of the best in the market. Their utter brilliance and sheen set them apart from other markers and pens by a long shot. Overall, these are quite a good investment.

Check Price Now

Best Pen for Baseball Autographs: Buying Guide

While all of the marker pens for baseball autographs reviewed above have been carefully picked by our team, you may still want to further narrow down your choice. To help you with that, we have listed down some of the things you need to look into when buying the best pen for your sports memorabilia.

Tip Size and Style

The first and most important factor worth considering is, of course, the size and style of tip you want for such a pen. Do you need wide, narrow, thin, or thick lines for the autographs you’ll be acquiring or any other needs you may satisfy with these pens? To better understand exactly what type of tip you need, it is important to understand the size of various tips.

Ballpoint pen: These pens have a tip size that is between 0.7 mm and 1.0 mm. However, this kind of tip is hard to use as an autograph pen unless you intend to sign only a small portion of the ball’s curved surface.

Broad tip: Anything that is more than 1.0 mm falls on the broader side of your pen tip options. This style of tip is perfect for autographs on larger writing surfaces like on basketballs or on large baseballs. They can be conveniently used on other surfaces that have more writing space as well.

Medium tip: Medium-tipped pens have nibs ranging between 0.31 mm and 0.5 mm, and these are typically the most neutral pen options on the list. If you do not want to go to either extreme and wish for something that falls right in the middle of most all pen options available, this is a good choice.

Extra-fine tip: These are extra-fine-tipped pens with tips that measure about 0.3 mm, and they usually have a more extensive range of functionality. These work best for activities like signing items, marking things, or writing on smooth surfaces. They also work well on smaller areas like photographs, ticket vouchers, and baseball cards.

Waterproof Features

Another very important factor worth considering is the extent to which a pen is waterproof or fade-resistant, which also includes numerous other factors such as correctability, quick drying, and permanence. When choosing a pen for baseball autographs or signatures, you need to consider the type of surface on which you will be writing.

As an example, if you plan to use the pen or marker for various tasks other than autographs and some of these other uses involve a variety of surfaces, a waterproof permanent marker is a more appropriate choice to ensure you are getting the most bang for your buck.


Baseball autograph pens come in two types of designs: capped and retractable. While the first type of pen is the basic style that everyone knows, the later design includes twistable and clickable options which can come in handy based on when and how you’ll be using those pens.

In the end, no particular design is superior to the other, and it completely boils down to your personal preference and determining which one works best for you.


Another very important factor worth considering is the level of precision required, and the one thing that can make pen lines look more crisp or refined is the compactness of the felt tip. It is precision which decides how nicely it settles on the surface. Not every marker or pen has this feature, regardless of its tip sizes and other features.

Some of the most expensive or fine-point pens may not have the highest level of precision. Also, a weak tip can blot the ink and make the lines look thicker and slightly faded around the edges. These issues do not look good on autographs.

When you are looking for permanent markers, this is one of the things that you need to keep in mind. To be on the safer side, we recommend that you go with the branded products as they will have reliable and more durable felt tips, but the same cannot be guaranteed in the case of less expensive products.

Rich Pigment

Besides the difference in the thickness of the felt tips, permanent markers and autograph pens may also differ widely in the darkness or richness of the ink color. We suggest a rich solid pigment that is opaque and incredibly vibrant when placed on a complementary color. This can make the lines look more visible in signatures and stand out even from a distance.

Having rich pigment also means the ink marks are less prone to blotting or fading around the edges. While diluted inks can work for simple marking, labeling, or visual aids, they may not be the perfect choice for autographs, calligraphy, signatures, and typography to look their best.

Also, remember that choosing cheaper autograph pens may result in heavy blotting when you apply this to a porous surface, and these may also smear on a non-porous surface. The lower quality pens may be low cost, but this lack of quality ink can heavily damage your project or spoil an autograph.

Fast-Drying and Smear-Free Ink

This is one of the most important features you will find in any good quality and well-rated autograph pen or marker. Nothing can be more upsetting than having a good artistic project or an autograph spoiled by accidentally brushing it or having the ink smear all over the surface.

As a result, pen makers have created special marking pens for autographs that have quick-drying ink. They dry very quickly after application. These pens are also resistant to fading and smudging, and notably, they work great for those who have sweaty palms or hands.

The high quality of ink used in these pens or markets results in faster drying progress and less mess on any type of surface. This also implies fewer repetitions and overlays to cover up any smudges or blotting. This feature makes a permanent marker the most feasible choice for taking autographs.

Comfortable Grip

Another very important thing that you need to remember and pay attention to is how the pen’s exterior is designed. These markers usually have a simple outer appearance, but they are ergonomically designed to ensure comfort when used for longer periods of time.

One thing that remains underappreciated is how the pen’s exterior is designed. Usually, permanent markers come with a simple and almost typical outer appearance, but for those that are ergonomically made, they can bring so much comfort when you’re using them for extended periods of time.

While there is no shortage of cheap pens and markers available out there, these more affordable options may not be as comfortable and can result in cramps in your wrist if someone has to sign many autographs. The retractable feature of some of these also adds to the comfort level to a considerable degree.

Permanent markers typically come with removable caps, but they have ridges in them to prevent them from rolling and falling off the table. Although it may seem minor, such small details go into making a pen easier and more comfortable to use.

Related Questions

How do you take care of your autograph pens?

To make the best use of your investment and make your pens last longer, we suggest that you cover the tips of the pens whenever they are not in use. You must avoid putting them in direct heat or sunlight as well, even with the cap on. Also, make sure that you store them properly capped with the tips facing down.

Can I revive a marker that was left open accidentally?

If you accidentally left a marker sitting out without a cap on, the ink can dry up quite quickly. However, there are a few ways in which you can revive a dried-up marker. For example, you can soak the felt tips in a bowl of alcohol for half a minute to soften the hardened ink that interrupts the flow, and this will get you some more use out of one of these.

What are some of the best things to get autographed by your favorite baseball player?

Some of the best things that you can get autographed by your favorite player include baseball bats, helmets, photos, jerseys, and game-used equipment. Each of these items can be displayed differently and have different values associated with them.